When a widely known gang cop died in a freeway crash after his shift ended on the central jail in Los Angeles, the doable whodunnit theories ran off the rails.
Authorities discovered beer bottles and a mattress in George Arthur’s “tricked-out get together van,” and it appeared like an unlucky case of DUI. However the 14-year police veteran had a protracted checklist of vicious enemies. Arthur had obtained demise threats from gang members, oversaw a “high-powered” part of the jail, and crashed mere steps from a “gang-infested” authorities housing venture downtown. Practically everybody in his orbit may have been a suspect if it turned out to be homicide. Episode 3, Season 5 of Accident, Suicide, or Murder traces the relentless detective work it took to unravel his mysterious demise.
Within the Nineteen Eighties, massive swaths of Los Angeles have been within the grip of turf wars waged by essentially the most infamous gangs within the nation. “The crack epidemic, PCP, and the proliferation of gangs and gang members introduced on against the law wave,” said Sgt. Richard Valdemar of the L.A. County Sheriff’s Dept.
The town averaged 1,100 to 1,200 homicides a yr, in accordance with LAPD detective Paul Coulter, “whereas in the present day they’ve 300 to 400. It’s nonetheless rather a lot, but it surely’s nothin’ prefer it was again then.”
Do not miss the newest in true crime:
Inventor’s Lies Exposed After Murdering Swedish Journalist During Submarine Trip
What Happened To These Twins After Their Millionaire Father Was Beaten To Death In Their Hamptons Home?
‘I Hope He’s Dead’: Woman Attempts Murder-Suicide At ‘Peanuts’ Headquarters
George Arthur’s Reason behind Loss of life
On the night of June 1, 1985, George Arthur had rolled out of the jail parking zone after his shift ended at 9:30 pm. By 10:00 pm, he was combating for his life after his van struck an embankment that divided two freeways. Arthur smashed the windshield together with his head, and there was blood in every single place — on the windshield and each the motive force and passenger sides. With beer cans tossed round his van, freeway patrol officers “conclude proper off that bat that it seems as if it’s a DUI,” stated Los Angeles reporter Tricia Takasugi.
Arthur died at an area hospital inside an hour, and a whole post-mortem was ordered, together with a toxicology report.
However the post-mortem outcomes surprised police: 4 bullets have been lodged at the back of his head. “They assume this escaped earlier discovery due to the quantity of trauma after the preliminary crash,” famous Takasugi. “We have been all shocked… this modified the entire path of the investigation,” stated Valdemar.
Simply by the character of his work, “George made lots of enemies,” he added.
Who was George Arthur?
Described as a “hero” in Accident, Suicide, or Homicide, Arthur had as soon as barely survived a violent shootout with gang members. He and his companion made a police coaching video in regards to the expertise referred to as A Will to Survive.
“So each new deputy who got here into our system knew who George Arthur was,” stated detective Shaun McCarthy. “He was type of a bigger-than-life character inside the ranks of the sheriff’s division.”
Arthur was married however amicably separated from his spouse, Linda Arthur, who was in Northern California when he died. She additionally labored for the Sheriff’s workplace, and the exes have been seeing different individuals, including a chance of a jealous lover into the combination.
Police uncover one other individual was within the van
Now that it was a murder investigation, the LAPD took the lead on the case. “They introduced out a complete [Police] Academy class to do a grid search,” stated McCarthy, and located a blood path happening the facet of a freeway to an space identified to be frequented by gang members.
Gun casings have been found within the van, and blood from the passenger windshield was despatched to the lab. DNA testing was unavailable in 1985, however police may determine blood sort, and so they quickly realized a second individual was within the car.
After police canvassed the neighborhood, two witnesses got here ahead with data. “They noticed two individuals close to the accident scene. One individual was seen working from the van within the path of a close-by housing venture. The opposite individual was seen kicking out the entrance windshield of the van after which working down that embankment off the facet of the freeway,” stated Takasugi.
RELATED: Idaho Jury Convicts Chad Daybell of Killing Wife and Lori Vallow’s 2 Children
A composite drawing led to a person who lived close by, who later admitted to stealing gadgets from the automobile, however he was not thought-about a suspect within the homicide.
At this level, Valdemar was turning over a number of situations in his thoughts: “Was he carjacked? Was some dangerous man hiding within the van when he drove away? His issues together with his spouse.” After all, somebody from the jail may have sneaked into his van.
So as to add to the confusion, a love triangle was not off the desk. A deputy had confronted Arthur a number of days earlier than the homicide about suspicions that Arthur was having an affair together with his spouse, however the lead in the end went nowhere.
The suspect checklist grows
“In our work, we took down among the greatest drug sellers in Los Angeles or their crews… [Arthur] knew them by title, and so they knew us,” said Valdemar, who labored with Arthur in a gang unit that focused the Mexican Mafia and a gang referred to as the Black Guerilla Household.
Two gang members had threatened Arthur’s life up to now, and Valdemar used his connections to trace them down. “I had a secure of informants, so I used to be continually going as much as jail to go to them,” stated Valdemar, however that in the end led nowhere.
After months of useless ends, police contacted the nationwide TV present America’s Most Needed providing a $10,000 reward, however even then, the case was chilly. “For me, this case was not gonna ever go chilly. George was my buddy; he was a hero within the division,” stated Valdemar. “I by no means let this go.”
Fourteen years later, the case is reopened
Quick-forward to 1999, and DNA know-how had superior signifcantly. The LAPD and Sheriff’s Division collectively reopened the case and examined the outdated blood samples from the blood path and contained in the van. With all of the gang leads exhausted, detectives McCarthy and Coulter took a recent have a look at George and Linda’s romantic escapades and started interviewing all their identified companions.
Whereas McCarthy was acquiring DNA samples from males related to Linda, he obtained a name from a colleague asking to fulfill. Over lunch, the individual handed the detective a post-it be aware with one title on it: Ted Kirby, a former colleague of George Arthur.
“I by no means noticed this title in any report. In any doc. In any pocket book. And we have been down to at least one individual to get DNA from: Ted Kirby,” in accordance with McCarthy.
Kirby was a retired sheriff’s deputy now dwelling in Spokane, Washington, together with his spouse.
RELATED: Judge in Scott Peterson Case Agrees to Retest Only One Piece of Evidence (DETAILS)
Investigators battle to acquire a DNA pattern from Ted Kirby
Detectives flew to Spokane to acquire a DNA pattern from Kirby, however the suspect grew to become uncooperative and employed a lawyer. What’s extra, an area choose refused to grant a courtroom order, citing a scarcity of possible trigger.
However the detectives got here up with a intelligent workaround: they pulled Kirby’s outdated time card information primarily based on the idea that whoever was within the van with Arthur that night time would have taken time without work from work after the homicide. There was blood from the suspect on the windshield, and that individual would have been injured.
It turned out that Kirby had taken off 12 sick days after the homicide — the one time in his profession he had taken prolonged sick time.
Additionally they reinterviewed Linda. “That’s when she opened up and began speaking about how he was very possessive. He would present up at social occasions she was invited to, however he wasn’t. He would drive by her home at night time,” stated McCarthy. Linda claimed she advised authorities in 1985 to take a look at Kirby, however nobody noticed his title within the unique supplies.
With this new data, the choose signed the courtroom order for a DNA swab and fingerprints. A match got here again first for the path of blood alongside the freeway, however the detectives bumped into yet one more roadblock. “The Chief of LAPD stated, ‘Nope, you’re not gonna arrest him. You place him outdoors the van, however you haven’t put him contained in the van but,’” recalled McCarthy.
Within the meantime, they searched Kirby’s Spokane residence and found he had disappeared, oddly leaving his wedding ceremony ring and pockets behind, however with out an arrest warrant, the native police wouldn’t seek for him.
A number of days later, DNA outcomes proved that Kirby was contained in the van, but it surely was too late. His physique had been discovered by native reporter Gary Darigol, who had been intently following the case and discovered about his mysterious disappearance. On July 14, 1999, Darigol and a information photographer searched the empty fields close to his residence and came across the grotesque discovery. Darigol remembered, “As we walked round, you don’t search for a physique. You scent the physique. And we did.”
Ted Kirby died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the pinnacle.
“One officer killing one other,” stated Valdemar solemnly. “It was simply unthinkable.”
See new episodes of Accident, Suicide, or Homicide, airing Saturdays at 8/7c on Oxygen.
